Buyers ask us this when a deal starts to feel shaky: the seller stops answering, an agent mentions “another offer,” or a family member suddenly does not want to sell. Sellers ask it when they are having second thoughts. The answer depends almost entirely on one question: has the contract become effective? Before that moment, either side can walk. After it, the contract decides.
Most Miami-Dade resales use the Florida Realtors/Florida Bar “AS IS” Residential Contract for Sale and Purchase. The current version is AS IS-7x, in use since March 1, 2026, and the paragraph numbers below refer to it. Your contract controls; read it with your agent, and talk to a Florida real estate attorney before acting on a dispute.
Before acceptance: the seller can say no
Florida Realtors’ own guidance is blunt: “A seller is not required to accept any offer. No one can force a seller to execute a contract.” Paragraph 3 of the contract sets the timing:

- The offer lapses. An offer not signed by both parties and delivered by the date written in the contract “shall be deemed withdrawn,” and the deposit is returned.
- Counter-offers have a clock. Unless stated otherwise, the time for accepting a counter-offer is two days after it is delivered.
- The Effective Date. It is the date the last of the buyer and seller signs or initials and delivers the final offer or counter-offer. Until then there is no contract.
One trap for sellers: Florida Realtors warns that a seller who sends counter-offers to two buyers, and both accept before one counter is withdrawn, “could be bound to multiple written contracts.” If you have competing offers, counter one at a time or say in writing that the counter is not binding until you sign it again.
After the Effective Date: the exits the contract gives a seller
Once the contract is effective, Standard F says “time is of the essence,” and the seller can leave only through specific doors. Most of them open because the buyer missed something.

- The buyer misses the deposit. The initial deposit is due within the days written in Paragraph 2, or three days after the Effective Date if left blank. Any additional deposit is due within ten days if left blank. Failing to pay “the Deposit, within the time(s) specified” is buyer default under Paragraph 15(a). The seller may then keep any deposit paid as liquidated damages or go to court to enforce the contract.
- The buyer does not deliver loan approval in time. In a financed deal, if the buyer delivers neither written notice of loan approval nor a waiver of the financing contingency by the end of the Loan Approval Period, Paragraph 8(b) lets the seller terminate “within 3 days after expiration of the Loan Approval Period.” The buyer’s deposit is refunded if the buyer is not otherwise in default.
- Title the seller cannot fix. Under Standard A, the seller has 30 days to cure title defects the buyer reports. If the seller cannot cure after reasonable diligent effort, the buyer chooses whether to extend, accept the title as it is, or terminate with the deposit back. Paragraph 15(b) specifically says that failing to make title marketable “after reasonable diligent effort” is not seller default. That is the honest seller’s exit; a seller who simply refuses to clear an easy lien does not get it.
- A long force majeure. Under Standard G, a hurricane, flood or similar event that keeps preventing performance “more than 30 days beyond Closing Date” lets either party terminate. Our note on hurricane season and a pending purchase covers how that interacts with insurance binding.
Doors that belong to the buyer, not the seller
Several well-known escape hatches are buyer rights and give a seller nothing.

- The inspection period in Paragraph 12(a) lets the buyer terminate if “in Buyer’s sole discretion” the property is not acceptable; it is 15 days if left blank.
- Risk of loss, Standard M, gives the buyer, not the seller, the choice when storm or fire damage exceeds 1.5% of the price.
- Condo and HOA document review rights are buyer protections too. Our guide to the Florida AS IS contract and inspection period walks through the buyer’s side.
Riders that change the answer
The seller’s options widen only if the parties agreed to them in writing before signing. Paragraph 19 lists the optional riders, including:

- Back-up Contract (W). The seller can sign a second contract that becomes effective only if the first one terminates.
- Kick-out Clause (X). Florida Realtors describes it as allowing sellers to keep entering into back-up contracts while requiring the first buyer to put down more money and waive contingencies, or step aside. It is common when a buyer’s offer depends on selling their current home.
- Seller’s Attorney Approval (Y). It gives the seller an attorney-review window. Without it there is none.
Florida Realtors also notes there is no three-day right to cancel a real estate contract unless the contract includes one.
| Situation | Can the seller walk away? | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Offer not yet signed and delivered by both sides | Yes | Paragraph 3; Florida Realtors |
| Buyer missed the deposit deadline | Yes, as buyer default | Paragraphs 2 and 15(a) |
| No written loan approval or waiver by end of Loan Approval Period | Yes, within 3 days after it expires | Paragraph 8(b) |
| Title defect not cured after diligent effort | The contract ends if the buyer will not accept title; deposit refunded | Standard A; Paragraph 15(b) |
| Force majeure more than 30 days past closing | Yes, either party | Standard G |
| Seller received a higher offer | No, unless a kick-out rider applies | Paragraph 15(b); Rider X |
| Seller changed their mind | No | Paragraph 15(b) |
Sources AS IS Residential Contract (ASIS-7x), Florida Realtors/Florida Bar; Florida Realtors, Florida Real Estate Contract Laws; Florida Realtors, optional clauses, riders and addenda.
When a seller refuses to close: the buyer’s remedies
If the seller “fails, neglects or refuses to perform” for any reason other than uncurable title, Paragraph 15(b) gives the buyer a choice. The buyer may “receive return of Buyer’s Deposit without thereby waiving any action for damages resulting from Seller’s breach,” and may sue for those damages or “seek specific performance.”

Specific performance means a court order requiring the seller to complete the sale. A Florida Realtors legal column explains why courts allow it: “each parcel of real estate is unique and irreplaceable.” The same column lays out the buyer’s realistic options when a seller wants out: let the seller off the hook, ask to be repaid their costs, or sue for specific performance. It adds that a seller who backs out may still owe the listing brokerage its commission.
Lis pendens. A buyer who sues can record a notice of lis pendens under Section 48.23. That tells anyone searching the title that a lawsuit affects the property, which in practice makes it very hard to sell to someone else while the case is pending. The protection has limits. Because a purchase contract is usually not recorded, the notice expires one year after the lawsuit is filed unless the court extends it for good cause, and the court can discharge it the way it would dissolve an injunction.
The process. Paragraph 16 gives buyer and seller ten days after conflicting demands for the deposit to resolve it themselves. Unresolved disputes then go to mediation before anyone goes to court.
What happens to the deposit in a dispute
When a brokerage holds the deposit and the parties make conflicting demands, the broker cannot simply pick a side. Florida’s rule for real estate brokers, 61J2-10.032, requires the broker to notify the Florida Real Estate Commission within 15 business days of the last party’s demand. Within 30 business days the broker must start one of the procedures in Section 475.25:

- an escrow disbursement order from the Commission;
- arbitration, if the parties consent;
- interpleader or other court action;
- mediation, with written consent.
If a title company or attorney holds the escrow, the contract’s escrow paragraph and that agent’s own rules apply instead.
How deals actually end: a mutual release
Most contracts that fall apart end with a signed Release and Cancellation of Contract for Sale and Purchase, the Florida Realtors form the parties use to cancel, release each other and say who gets the deposit. Nobody is required to sign it. A seller who wants out of a contract without a legal exit is, in practice, negotiating for a release: returning the deposit, often covering the buyer’s inspection and appraisal costs, and sometimes paying more.

If you are under contract and the other side is wobbling, call us before you send anything in writing. Our buyer representation and selling pages explain how we manage contracts from offer to closing.
Sources
- Florida Realtors/Florida Bar, AS IS Residential Contract for Sale and Purchase (ASIS-7x), redlined edition: https://www.floridarealtors.org/sites/default/files/2026-02/AS%20IS%20Residential%20Contract%20for%20Sale%20and%20Purchase%20%28FloridaRealtors-FloridaBar-ASIS-7x%29_Redlined%5B1%5D.pdf
- Florida Realtors, “FinCEN Rule, Rider Updates Take Effect” (February 26, 2026): https://www.floridarealtors.org/news-media/news-articles/2026/02/fincen-rule-rider-updates-take-effect
- Florida Realtors, Florida Real Estate Contract Laws: https://www.floridarealtors.org/law-ethics/library/florida-real-estate-contract-laws
- Florida Realtors, “Think You Know Optional Clauses, Riders and Addenda?” (September 26, 2023): https://floridarealtors.org/news-media/news-articles/2023/09/think-you-know-optional-clauses-riders-and-addenda
- Florida Realtors, “Seller: Can We Get Out of a Deal to Sell Our Home?” (Gary M. Singer, November 2, 2023): https://www.floridarealtors.org/news-media/news-articles/2023/11/seller-can-we-get-out-deal-sell-our-home
- Florida Statutes §48.23, Lis pendens: https://www.flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2026/48.23
- Florida Statutes §475.25, Discipline (escrow disputes): https://www.flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2026/475.25
- Florida Administrative Code Rule 61J2-10.032, Conflicting Demands and Good Faith Doubt: https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/florida/Fla-Admin-Code-Ann-R-61J2-10-032
- RWorld / Florida Realtors, “The Law Says Contracts…” on the Release and Cancellation form (October 19, 2020): https://rworld.com/blog/law-says-contracts


